Articles Comments



Beernem (Belgium), 13th May 2014:  On Tuesday 13th May 2014,  Tibetaanse-Vlaamse Vriendenkring (Tibetan-Flemish Circle of Friends) has organized a peaceful silent demonstration for the Tibetan refugees in Belgium in front of the building of the Council for Foreigners Disputes in Brussels. The action was an initiative of our special Working Group “Help for Tibetans in Flanders”.

About 118 people in total have participated in the manifestation, around 110 Tibetans and 8 Belgian Tibet supporters. The silent demonstration lasted one hour and twenty minutes. Slogans were shown on placards: “India never signed the refugee convention”, “Tibet -> India -> Belgium -> no man’s land?”, “We have never been recognized as refugees”, “In Tibet oppression, in India uncertainty, in Belgium uncertainty, where is our future?”, “We are not Chinese, no Indians, we are Tibetans… who welcomes us?”, “We had temporary shelter, no asylum in India!”, “We have no voice” etc.     

Untitled-3The occasion for this demonstration was the change in Belgian law since 8th May 2013 that is in effect since 1st September 2013, namely Article 48/5§4 of the Foreigners Act that says “there is no need for international protection if the asylum seeker already is protected in a first country of asylum, unless he can prove that he can no longer count on the concrete protection in the first country of asylum, or that he is no longer admitted to the territory of that country.

According to Article 48/5, §4 of the Foreigners Act, “a country can be seen as a first country of asylum in case the asylum seeker is recognized as refugee and that he therefor is still protected, or that he is really protected in that country, including the principle of non-refoulement.

This new law has very serious concequences, particulary for refugees of Tibetan origin, more so taking into account that before this law 90% of Tibetan asylum seekers was granted the status of refugee (according to Art. 48/3 Foreigners Act) by the Commissariat-General for Refugees and Stateless.

Since the new law, the asylum appplications of Tibetan refugees are systematically being rejected, with all consequences.

Almost all Tibetans escaping their country go to India first, to meet their spiritual leader H.H. the Dalai Lama and to be educated in Tibetan and about buddhism, the Tibetan culture and traditions, because this is strictly forbidden in China and Tibet.

A change in the asylum regulations makes that all those Tibetans no longer get asylum in Belgium because the Commisariat for Refugees considers India as “first country of asylum”. This is strange because India never ratified the United Nations international agreements on asylum, so asylum procedures do not exist in India and refugees therefore cannot get asylum in India.

Already a few hundred Tibetans have been denied asylum in Belgium as a consequence of this law. The Commissariat forUntitled-2 Refugees urges Tibetans to return to India, and they consider that this can be done easily just by getting the necessary travel documents at the Indian Embassy in Brussels. Some Tibetans have tried to apply for the necessary documents like the IC (Identity Certificate) at the Indian Embassy but didn’t get any and therefor cannot return to India.

The result of all this is that a few hundred Tibetans are stranded in a kind of no man’s land now… and that group is growing day by day.

A lot of Tibetan refugee cases were handled by the Judges of the Council for Foreigners Disputes in Brussels already. The first judgments have been issued for Tibetans born in India. The Council follows the decisions of the Commissariat for Refugees, namely that those people have to return to India, but the Council has decided so without further investigation into their status in India. We are still waiting for the judgements for Tibetans born in Tibet, but without much hope.

On Tuesday 13th May 2014 several cases of Tibetans were handled on the Council for Foreigners Disputes again. On this occasion the Tibetan-Flemish Circle of Friends organised this peaceful silent demonstration in front of the Council to give a signal to the Judges concerning this new law and to express their displeasure and deep concern about this new law in the asylum procedure.

With this demonstration we ask the Council to investigate the situation of the Tibetans thoroughly  and to seek a solution for their hopeless situation. We find it unacceptable that their asylum is being rejected on the basis that they already got “a status” in India, and that a return to India is impossible. More and more Tibetans are being left without support or care, and will be forced into illegality.

If necessary, we are planning more peaceful actions for Tibetans without papers in the future.




Dennis Barbion (Karma Dondub) is a Tibet supporter, Buddhist and human rights activist based in Belgium. Currently he is the President of Tibetaanse-Vlaamse Vriendenkring (Tibetan-Flemish Circle of Friends). v.z.w. Tibetaanse-Vlaamse Vriendenkring (Tibetan-Flemish Circle of Friends – Belgium)

tel. 0032- (president Dennis Barbion)

Written by

Filed under: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply